Consider this: What if we stopped looking for the worst in everything? What if we stopped constantly amplifying negativity?
I recently came across a post about a psychology experiment that made me stop my scroll. It was far more fascinating than most of the unwanted crap that pops up on my feed. It really got me thinking about how much our expectations influence the way we experience the world.
The post described a group of women who had realistic-looking scars applied to their faces before meeting with strangers. They were told the experiment would examine how people treated them because of their appearance. Right before the interactions, researchers supposedly touched up the makeup but secretly removed the scars instead.
The women went into their meetings believing they had noticeable facial scars. Afterward, they described how people looked at them differently, behaved awkwardly, or treated them poorly because of their appearance. Except that the scars weren't even there, as they thought.
Take a minute and think about that one. Really think about it!
Naturally, I wanted to know whether this experiment actually happened, so I went looking for the research. Turns out, it did, although the social media version takes a few liberties...as to be expected.
The original study was published in 1980 by psychologists Robert Kleck and Angelo Strenta. The researchers examined how believing you have a negatively perceived physical characteristic can affect your interpretation of other people's behavior. The first experiment involved 24 female college students, and the interactions were conversations with another person.
The researchers found that participants who believed they had a facial scar were more likely to interpret the other person's behavior as a reaction to their appearance, even though the scar had been removed prior to the interaction. 😮
In other words, what they believed other people were seeing influenced what they believed other people were thinking. 🤯
Now, before anyone runs with this as proof that discrimination does not exist, let's be clear. It absolutely does. There are plenty of documented examples of people being treated unfairly because of their appearance, race, gender, and other characteristics. This experiment does not erase any of those experiences.
However, it DOES suggest that our expectations can influence how we interpret the world around us, sometimes without our even realizing it. THAT is what sent me down a deep dark rabbit hole.
How often do we go into a situation expecting someone to be rude, judgmental, dishonest, or difficult, only to interpret everything they do through that lens? Someone doesn't smile, and we assume they are unfriendly. Someone doesn't respond to a text message immediately, and we decide they are ignoring us. Someone disagrees with us, and suddenly we are convinced they don't respect us.
It's possible they are actually being a jerk. Lord knows there are plenty of those running around! However, it's also possible they are just distracted, exhausted, worried about something, or simply having a shitty day. How often do we give people the benefit of the doubt anymore?
This got me really thinking about the bigger picture. Every day, we are bombarded with news about violence, corruption, cruelty, division, and lately all the ways the world is coming to an end. Open social media, turn on the television, or glance at the headlines, and it is easy to come away believing humanity has completely lost its mind.
I am not suggesting those things aren't happening. Some probably are, and they deserve our attention. But but but...what about all the GOOD things that are happening?!?
What about the stranger who helps someone change a flat tire? What about the neighbor who quietly takes care of an elderly friend? What about the teacher who goes above and beyond for a struggling student? What about the thousands of ordinary acts of kindness happening every single day that never make the news because, apparently, being a decent human being isn't very exciting.
What if we gave those stories more attention than the ugly ones? What if we amplified love and turned the volume down on hate?
What if the news spent as much time showing us people helping each other as it does showing us how we hurt and hate one another? What if our social media feeds were filled with examples of (real) generosity, compassion, creativity, and people helping people?
Would we start expecting more goodness from the world? Would we notice if more often? Would we be more inclined to contribute to it ourselves?
I regularly think about Michael Jackson's song, Heal the World. Could we? 🤔
If our expectations can influence how we interpret an ordinary conversation, imagine what constantly expecting the worst might do to how we see our communities, our neighbors, and even people we've never even met. I've even wondered what would happen if we stopped giving so much attention to ugliness entirely. If the terrible things people do stopped receiving endless headlines, shares, and commentary, would some of that behavior lose its appeal? Maybe. Maybe not. But...probably.
Of course, ignoring problems doesn't make them disappear. We need to know about injustice, corruption, and danger so we can do something about them. Pretending everything is wonderful while people are suffering is not optimism...it's denial.
Still, I wonder whether there is a healthier balance somewhere between being informed and being completely consumed by everything that's wrong with the world. We can't control every headline, and we are certainly not going to convince the entire media industry to replace its programming with puppies, random acts of kindness, and heartwarming reunions. But...if that channel existed, I would absolutely watch it!
What we CAN do is pay more attention to what we are choosing to consume, share, and believe. We CAN look for the good without pretending the bad doesn't exist. We CAN question our assumptions before deciding someone has terrible intentions. We CAN share the stories of people doing wonderful things instead of giving every ounce of our attention to the people doing terrible ones.
Maybe we would start noticing a little more kindness. If we did that, perhaps we would become a little more patient...and maybe...just maybe...even inspire someone else to do something good.
I don't know whether any of that would change the world, but I can't help but wonder what happen if enough of us tried. What if the world isn't quite as terrible as we've been conditioned to believe? What if we are just spending so much time looking for the worst, we are overlooking an awful lot of the best?
Am I alone in this? Does constantly hearing about everything wrong with the world change how you see people? Would more positive news make a difference, or would we risk becoming dangerously uninformed?
I don't have the answers, but I would love to see what would happen if we spent a little more time expecting good. I think if we expect to find it, we will.